1) What next for the Premier League?
An extraordinary few days in English football became official on Tuesday afternoon when the Premier League confirmed eight-time champions – and current league leaders – Manchester City have been found guilty, by an independent commission, of all charges relating to financial rule breaches between the 2009/10 and 2017/18 seasons. An unusually emotive and strident statement – referencing “sham contracts” and a “disguised funding scheme” – from the Premier League, followed initial reporting of the guilty verdicts by The Athletic’s David Ornstein last Friday, the catalyst for days of frenzied analysis and speculation about what happens next. The ramifications and potential repercussions are enormous for both the past and the future of the Premier League and its reputation. And kudos at this point must go to CEO Richard Masters and Chair Alison Brittain for seeing through a tortuous, sensitive and expensive process. It’s been a huge effort to uphold sporting integrity even if that results in damage to the Premier League’s product and reputation, not least in the vacuum period that now exists as the sanctioning and any appeals process plays out. And to the Premier League’s General Counsel Kevin Plumb, who has led the line through a process that has occupied much of the last decade.
2) What next for Manchester City?
City are digging in, continuing to deny the guilty verdict, signalling its intent to appeal (it has until Friday to formally commit to that) and insisting it has “irrefutable” evidence that will clear its name. In times of crisis and uncertainty, it’s natural to look to leadership for guidance – CEO Ferran Soriano fronted a video for City staff (which was immediately leaked) on Tuesday, after Chair Khaldoon Al-Mubarak penned an initial open letter to fans on Saturday. Perhaps the most critical role in the coming weeks and months is held by Carolyn MacNab, City Football Group’s Chief People Officer, who will be tasked with communicating with and perhaps pacifying a workforce that now numbers around 1,800 if you include CFG’s network of clubs around the world, the vast majority of whom have had nothing to do with the boardroom-level transgressions. The ramifications for the club, should an appeal fail and the kind of extreme sanctions being talked of applied, are wide. Abu Dhabi has become so woven into the fabric of the city of Manchester, particularly the area around the Etihad Stadium, and national relations between the UK and UAE may be tested.
3) Has there ever been a better time to be a sports lawyer?
With the independent commission’s verdict now in, the prospect of a cascade of related legal action being brought against City from wronged rival clubs, and perhaps even individual players, agents or commercial partners, is a touch mind-bending but very real. The only guarantee is law firms will be in demand, as the recent history of top-flight English football is reinterpreted. I do find the idea of sports lawyers as recognisable, main player, figures - there to be analysed and rated, strengths and weaknesses examined in the same way as players - faintly ridiculous, but here we are. Anecdotally, we have more law firms than ever attending Leaders Week London next week - that’s no coincidence in a world where financial regulation (salary caps, budget caps, sustainability rules) have ballooned across a variety of sports.
4) Can a punishment be fun?
There’s been plenty of creative thinking around possible sanctions for City, and it seems certain heavy sporting penalties will be applied. Relegation to the Championship, or even further down the English football pyramid, has been suggested. The EFL must be licking its lips at that prospect – if, for example, it had a humbled City playing in its leagues for at least three seasons (if the club was relegated to League 2) that’s enough time to directly impact a broadcast rights sales cycle. A further suggestion of Premier League points deductions over a number of seasons does also add a fascinating new sporting and jeopardy element to the product. Justice will be done, but there’s potentially a way to do it that, at the same time, boosts interest and audience.
5) Can you make the matinée?
NHL President of Business Keith Wachtel will be with us next week in London, alongside NHLPA Chief International Officer, Rob Zepp, and as the new season starts I’m keen to ask them about the NHL’s decision to schedule at least nine Monday lunchtime regular season games this season. They’ll be beamed into European markets at prime time, a further sign of the NHL’s commitment to its international project, which, for now at least, is centred on Germany. The league has also this week signed a new wide-ranging partnership with Adobe.
6) Where does your boss want to be seen?
In a rare moment when the increasingly unhinged LinkedIn algorithm worked in my favour, I was served up this post by PR executive Kate Dmytrenko this week. She’s summarising a recent survey by business Inc. Magazine in which over 100 PR and comms people were asked which media outlets founders want most. So called ‘legacy’ media holds up very well, she reports - and says that’s partly because for all the very good podcasts and Substacks clogging up feeds, it’s Bloomberg, Fortune and the New York Times that still make the cut for board and investor pitch decks. In the newer media space Axios plays well, according to one respondent, as it tends to be cited often by three major LLMs, as do podcasts published on YouTube.
7) How do they organise those confetti cannons?
Wonder no more, thanks to the folks at the MCG.